11th Pastor 2020-
Rev. John J. Costello
Installed October 18, 2020
10th Pastor 2005-2020
Rev. Msgr. John C. Tosi
+May 23, 2020
9th Pastor 1983-2005
Rev. Msgr. Nicholas J. Capua
8th Pastor 1966-1983
Rev. Msgr. John J. Gorman
7th Pastor 1918-1965
Rev. Msgr. Francis J. Dillon
+September 15, 1965
Rev. William F. Matters
Administrator 1963-1965
6th Pastor 1904-1918
Rt. Rev. Msgr. Thomas J. O'Brien
+August 26, 1939
5th Pastor 1895-1904
Rev. John F. O'Hara
+April 17, 1916
4th Pastor 1885-1895
Rev. Peter Kearney
+July 20, 1908
3rd Pastor 1880-1885
Rev. William Connolly
+February 13, 1886
2nd Pastor 1872-1880
Rev. Francis J. Blake
+September 2, 1892
Founding Pastor 1870-1872
Rev. William McCloskey
+June 18, 1872